Saturday, July 14, 2012

Benjamin Rayer, New Jersey's King Of The Cybercharters

This is the story of Benjamin Rayer, and how he got approval for not one, but TWO charter schools from the NJDOE.  It's an unlikely story, since our protagonist isn't even a resident of our fair state!!  But that didn't deter Benjamin from applying as the lead founder for both charters, no siree!  After all, he knew he had the right reformy qualifications to get ahead in New Jersey!


He is on the Springfield Township Board of Education in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania.  As you can see, his short bio on the district website lists his most impressive qualifications:


Having connections to Broad will certainly get you places in New Jersey!


But it also says he's CEO of Touchstone Education.  What's that?
Touchstone Education operates high-performing secondary schools that are changing the landscape of education across America. By integrating modern technology and best in class education strategies, we provide every student with a personalized education that ensures that all of our students are accepted to college and are prepared for the worlds of work and life.
So how many schools is Touchstone Education currently operating to back up this claim that they "are changing the landscape of education across America."  


None.  


Touchstone is a start-up charter management organization (CMO), and Merit Prep Newark will be the first school it operates.  


Hmm.


But, they must be great, because they have some big plans and big money.  After all, the Charter School Growth Fund has given Touchstone $3.6M.

Rayer, founder of Touchstone Education, a charter management organization (CMO), does not hide that he hopes to take his model national. He has already drawn impressive sums from some big names in education reform. 
One is the Charter School Growth Fund in Colorado, which is putting up more than $3.6 million for Rayer’s CMO. The fund is headed by Kevin Hall, the former president of the Broad Foundation, a big force in education reform circles.

Ah, one Broadie scratching the back of another Broadie.  And really Mr. Mooney?  A "big force?"  That may be the understatement of the century...


The Charter School Growth Fund website states:

Portfolio Member Profile:

Touchstone Education is a new school management organization that will operate secondary (grades 6-12) blended learning schools across the United States. Touchstone will open its inital charter schools in Newark and Trenton, New Jersey in August 2012. Touchstone was created to reimagine secondary school by combining effective instructional practices and new technology to deliver personalized learning programs so that students are prepared to succeed in college and in life.

Planned Impact:

During the first phase of Touchstone's growth, it plans to launch six schools in New Jersey that will ultimately create over 3,600 new seats of student capacity in blended learning secondary schools.
New Jersey is just the "first phase" before he takes Touchstone national.  And man, does he have some big plans for New Jersey or what?


Why did he pick New Jersey as a stepping stone instead of his home state of Pennsylvania?  Let's take a look at when his charters were approved and see if we get any answers there, beyond the obvious Broad connections which seem to have served him pretty well thus far in our story.  


Both of Rayer's charters were approved in the 2011 expedited round of applications.  If you look at the list in the link you will note that this was the first time he applied as well, so he hit a grand slam his first time at bat.  Pretty impressive.  He applied for Newark Prep Charter School (Now called Merit Prep Newark) and Trenton Prep Charter School (Now called Merit Prep Trenton), and both won approval.  They were two of eight applications approved in that round.  

Carly Bolger oversaw that round of applications as the Director of the Office of Charter Schools, until she left at the end of 2011, supposedly for "personal reasons." Turns out, Bolger and Rayer both worked for the Philadelphia School District's Office of Charter, Partnership, & New Schools, and they worked there at the SAME TIME.  Rayer was her boss.  


 Benjamin W. Rayer  Chief, Charter, Partnership & New Schools Officer 
 Timothy Field Deputy
 Carly Bolger Coordinator, Charter Schools
 Doresah Ford-Bey Manager
 Dee Gardner Confidential Secretary
 Stacy Goodman Coordinator, Charter Schools
 Adrienne F. Hawkins Coordinator, Teacher Advancement Program
 Susan Ostrich TAP Director-Philly TAP
 Darcy Russotto, Ph.D           TAP Specialist
 Margaret Sears, Ed.D TAP Specialist
 Yvonne L. Soto Coordinator, Innovation and Partnership Programs   


Looks like the stars really aligned for our protagonist.  A Broad infested NJDOE, Broad buddies with big money, and a former employee running the application process in New Jersey!  

And where will Merit Prep Newark be located?  It will be co-located at 909 Broad Street in Newark, along with TEAM, KIPP and Newark Collegiate Academy, so it would seem that Rayer has been welcomed with open arms by the established Newark charter elite as well.



In case you think all of this was an easy feat, the story of Tom Vander Ark will dispel that notion.  

Vander Ark is no slouch himself.  He was the former Executive Director of Education for the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, and was also poised to run two cybercharters in New Jersey, Newark Prep (approved as Vailsburg Prep) and Spirit Prep, and he also had approval for a cybercharter in Brooklyn.  He had his own CMO too, called City Prep Academies, and Vander Ark claimed he was also going to get money from the Charter School Growth Fund.  


Mr. Vander Ark had been unable to get any money from the Charter School Growth Fund or other similar national organizations. He had basically abandoned the idea of beginning a charter management organization and left the three schools-in-progress to find outside help on their own.
Mr. Tillotson, the consultant, said: “It signals what’s wrong with the so-called charter school community. Somebody who doesn’t deserve a charter gets a charter. Somebody who doesn’t deserve a building gets a building. And then somebody who doesn’t care about the communities can turn their head and walk away.”
Without the big money from the Charter School Growth Fund, despite his pedigree, Vander Ark just couldn't get his charters off the ground.  Now Newark Prep and Spirit Prep are in the hands of K12 Inc., but that's a story for another day...  For the purposes of our story, it looks like Rayer's Broad connections at the Charter School Growth Fund may have been the difference between success and failure.  

There is just one last chapter left to tell in the story of Benjamin's ascention.  In case you haven't put it together yet, Benjamin is both the lead founder of the charters AND the CEO of the CMO.  This was made abundantly clear in the application for the charter.  (See pages 57-58).  Touchstone was originally called Platform Academies, and remember Merit Prep Newark was approved as Newark Preparatory Charter School (I know, it is hard to keep track with all of this name-changing!)
After the charter is granted and pending Board approval, Newark Preparatory Charter School will enter into a management contract with a high-performing non-profit charter management organization (CMO).
If approved, the CMO will provide management, operations and instructional program consulting services to Newark Preparatory Charter School.   The CMO will be responsible for providing the overall academic program and tools to execute and apply at Newark Preparatory Charter School. The CMO will also manage all business operations of the school including financial management, facilities and human resources.  Newark Preparatory Charter School will negotiate with the selected CMO to determine a fee that will be in the range of 12% of the school’s local and state share of equalization aid. The term of the contract is expected to be one-year and can be renewed annually. The contract can be terminated with cause. The contract may also be terminated upon written agreement of both parties.  
Newark Preparatory Charter School will consider a contract with Platform Academies, a non-profit school management organization which is launching schools in NJ for the first time in the fall of 2012, with strategic guidance and financial support from the Charter School Growth Fund of CO.  For Year 1, Platform Academies has agreed to waive, if necessary, the CMO fee in the event that it would cause a budget deficit.  Therefore, the fee is not included in the planning budget at this time.  Newark Preparatory Charter School will also follow all applicable NJ vendor bidding regulations by seeking bids from at least 2 other high-performing CMO’s.  However, given that the Lead Founder of Newark Preparatory Charter School, Ben Rayer, is also the Founder and CEO of Platform Academies Incorporated, we have included information about Platform Academies’ business plan here.  (emphasis mine)
The Office of Charter Schools actually questioned Rayer on this very point in a Request for Addenda to the application, and wanted assurances that all transactions would be at "arm's length." (See pages 4-5).   The only concrete assurance given was that if Rayer's CMO won the bid (*cough*) to run the charter, Rayer would not be on the Board of Trustees.  


I don't know about you, but that doesn't reassure me too much.  


I would like to see the RFP's that went out looking for two other "high-performing CMO's" that may have been able to provide these services to the taxpayers of New Jersey for less than "the range of 12%."  Amazing how Rayer's CMO, which remember, is a start-up, managed to come out on top and get the contract for a high-performing CMO!    


I'd also like to know who is on the Board of Trustees. Then maybe we would could find out how this decision was made.  Just knowing that supposedly Rayer isn't on the board doesn't really impress me.  


I have scoured the Merit Prep website, and all I can come up with as a contact is Erika Ellison, Director of Operations for Touchstone Education.  Anyone else think it's peculiar that the only contact for the charter works for the CMO?  No principal or lead person contact information, just someone from corporate who seems to have no background in education, other than working for Mastery Charter Schools, where coincidentally Rayer was the Chief Operating Officer before he worked for, and mysteriously resigned from, the School District of Philadelphia.  


There is no list of Board Members either.  No list of meeting dates, or minutes of previous meetings, which you will find on just about any district website.


And look at this statement about the influence Vander Ark had on the charters he was planning to manage:
The newspaper first reported in early July the news about the diminished role of Vander Ark, who had provided essential services such as professional writing for the charter application, forming the charter school boards, footing lawyer fees, and initial interviews for staff. (emphasis mine)
So forgive me if I don't buy that Rayer has had no influence on the appointment of the Board of Trustees, especially since we have no idea who they are and how they decided to select his CMO to run the schools for which he also served as Lead Founder.


So, that's how you do it friends. That's how you get yourself poised to open a whole slew of charters in New Jersey, and if you're successful there, maybe the nation.  You just need the right connections to get a couple approvals and a lot of money.  


Then make sure there is no public trail of the bid for your CMO to run the chain of charters you got approved and voilĂ , you're the self appointed King of Cybercharters in New Jersey!


Friday, July 13, 2012

Rolling The Dice; One In Three Approved Charters In New Jersey Can't Cut The Mustard

As I sit here waiting to find out if the NJDOE will release the list of final charters today, I can't help but wonder how many brand new charters will be opening this Fall.  


When the last round of eight approvals was announced in January of this year, the NJDOE stated that thirty three charters would be eligible to open in September of 2012.  I guess with Regis Academy getting thrown under the charter school bus that total is down to thirty two.   This morning Jersey Jazzman pointed out that Regis should never have been given the green light in the first place.

The takeaway here is that the NJDOE's charter application and oversight processes are hopelessly broken. 


I would imagine that anyone that reads my or Jersey Jazzman's blog would probably agree with this statement.  We have seen time and time and time again, that the application process is a "make it up as you go along" fiasco. 


If every application was put under the same microscope as Tikun Olam, Regis Academy and Garden State Virtual Charter School, and the communities involved were informed and felt empowered to participate in the process, we would see far more applications denied and far fewer doors opening.  


And magical things don't just automatically start happening for students and parents just because a charter school's doors do open. Clearly, there are some serious oversight struggles going on as well.  
In fact, some doors open into charter school buildings with no students inside...     


They have concluded the state sent Adelaide Sanford Charter school hundreds of thousands of dollars to lease the James Street building over the past 16 months. According to a state Department of Education report obtained by The Star-Ledger, the children were being educated somewhere else.


OOPS.


Jessica Calefati's excellent piece goes on to point out that:
Twelve other charters are also on probation now because of academic, fiscal or operational problems, according to state Department of Education records.


You need a score card to keep up with what charters are even open, let alone on probation, approved but waiting to receive a final charter, or being awarded their first, second, or possibly even third planning year.
Since we don't have the report Cerf has been promising for quite some time now, let's just take a look at some basic facts available on the NJDOE website to see if we can get a handle on what's going on.

According to the NJDOE's "New Jersey Charter School Fact Sheet", as of January 2012, there were 80 operating charter schools in New Jersey. 

And remember, above we said there are thirty two awaiting their final charter.  Let's just pretend they all get the green light.  That would be a 40% increase in the number of charter schools in one year!  


There is also a very telling list at the bottom of the Charter School Fact Sheet I linked to above.  It contains names of approved charters that:
  • had applications approved but were denied a final charter (five - not including Regis)
  • were operational but had their charters revoked (eleven - not including Emily Fischer)
  • surrendered their charters either after the application was approved or after opening (TWENTY!!) 
  • were open for "the life of at least one charter" but were not renewed (four)
That's a total of FOURTY CHARTERS that have been approved but just couldn't cut the mustard.  


SInce there are eighty charters up and running, and forty that never got off the ground, there is a one in three chance that an approved application will not make it in the state of New Jersey.  

Clearly, the NJDOE's current issues with oversight of the application process is not a new phenomenon, and despite the constant assurances of increased accountability, charters like Regis still blow up in their face.  

If the one in three trend continues, out of the current batch of thirty two charters awaiting final approval, which ten will backfire on the NJDOE?  And more importantly, how many students are enrolled for the 2012/2013 school year?  

Saturday, July 7, 2012

We Can't Allow NJDOE To Deflect Blame For Regis Fiasco!

ONE,

TWO,

THREE...

FOUR!
Regis Decision

I hate to say I told ya so, but...


District officials and community members have been alerting the Office of Charter Schools for months that eviction proceedings were underway.  How that office saw fit to move forward with a preparedness visit on a facility that seems to have materialized out of thin air, is beyond me.  

Amir Khan and the NJDOE need to release the terms of Amir Khan's "deal" with the owners of the former Living Faith Christian Academy, and they need to release them NOW! 

And this is from the above letter...

At no point during the site visit or thereafter did Regis seek to explain the ownership of the property, or Solid Rock's ability to lease the property to Regis, which is particularly curious given the prior issues that Solid Rock had with the Original Facility.

Ya know what I find "particularly curious?"  That the Office of Charter Schools didn't REQUIRE that information before they conducted the preparedness visit at the "New Facility" when the effected districts and communities had been informing that office for MONTHS that they were facing eviction from their "Original Facility."


PLEASE!

To throw Amir Khan under the charter school bus deflects blame from where it belongs - squarely of the Broad (pun intended - check the link!) shoulders of Acting Commissioner Cerf's New Jersey Department of Education and Amy Ruck's Office of Charter Schools. 

By inspecting that "New Facility" the NJDOE became complicit co-conspirators, and to not accept that blame along with Amir Khan is disingenuous at best.

This is why this battle will rage on.  It was very clear early on in my battle with Tikun Olam that the issues involved were not specific to that application.  The NJDOE gives the districts effected by an application absolutely NO VOICE in the application process.  And the more districts fight back against this disenfranchisement, the more, according to the DOE and charter proponents, they are "defending the status quo" or "protecting the interests of adults, not children."

PLEASE!

Tikun Olam and Regis are perfect case studies of what happens when the people are ignored, and the agenda of an unaccountable state agency is allowed to supersede the good sense and judgement of the local community.

This WILL NOT stop until we stop battling district by district and we start fighting as a STATE.  

Please, take the time now to sign up for Save Our Schools NJ to stay informed and sign our petition which will tell your legislators that you want local control over charter school approvals.  Read Jersey Jazzman as often as you can.  


Stay engaged, stay informed, and stay strong!

The quote below was left as a comment on the Facebook page of Speak Up South Jersey, on a post congratulating Rita McClellan, tireless parent advocate for the Cherry Hill schools, on her resounding victory.  I found it truly inspiring, and I hope it inspires all of you to stay involved!  


The children of New Jersey need all of us to keep fighting!  On to the next battle!!  



"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed 

people can change the world.  Indeed, it is the only thing that 

ever has."  - Margaret Mead

Friday, July 6, 2012

egREGIouS Behavior

NOW Amir Khan can't comment?

"We understand persecution, and you just push forward through every obstacle," said Khan, who declined to explain the church's decision to stop fighting the eviction. "We're not going away. Our church is about to celebrate 20 years in ministry and we're going stronger than ever before."

What impact the move could have on Khan's charter ambition is unclear. Khan said he still planned to open Regis, which would be a secular public institution, in time for the coming school year. He declined to say where it would be.
A New Jersey Department of Education spokesman said Thursday that Regis planned to locate in the former Living Faith Christian Academy on the Cooper River in Cherry Hill and that state officials had recently inspected the facility.
"I want to be careful. I can't comment on that," Khan said when asked about the property. (emphasis mine)
Oh, and what a coincidence!  The owner of the "new facility," Living Faith Ministries, wouldn't comment either!
So what are the terms established between Amir Khan and Living Faith Ministries, the owner of the property?
Maybe the DOE knows, but the public sure doesn't!
Solid Rock WC has received mortgage approval 
and 
the State preparedness visit has been re-scheduled for 6/27/12 at 2:00 PM 
So, six days before the preparedness visit at a PUBLIC MEETING Amir Khan, PRESIDENT of the Board of Trustees conveniently FORGOT to mention where that visit would take place?  
This is all very, very fishy.
Solid Rock has faced an eviction lawsuit from Holy Eucharist Parish of Cherry Hill, the property’s owner. The dispute’s status could not be determined Thursday.
That's odd, because community activists had no problem uncovering the following details:
  • June 15th a "warrant for removal" was issued
  • June 15th a lawyer for Solid Rock Worship Center tried to get an emergency stoppage of the removal.
  • June 25th the warrant was given to a court officer which would lock them out of the property
  • July 13th court date set for a motion to reinstate
These details were confirmed with Camden Diocese spokesman Peter Feuerherd.

When Amir Khan "reported," to his Board of Trustees and the PUBLIC that he had a mortgage and the preparedness visit date had been changed, he had to know that he was about to be locked out.

District officials and community members have been alerting the Office of Charter Schools for months that eviction proceedings were underway.  How that office saw fit to move forward with a preparedness visit on a facility that seems to have materialized out of thin air, is beyond me.  

Amir Khan and the NJDOE need to release the terms of Amir Khan's "deal" with the owners of the former Living Faith Christian Academy, and they need to release them NOW! 

Oh dear, we wouldn't want to interrupt Amir Khan's vacation though...

But Thursday, Khan remained upbeat, saying he was on vacation with his wife and trying to relax ahead of the state's decision about whether the charter could open in two months' time.
"Like everyone else, we just have to sit and wait," he said.
I can assure you Pastor Khan, the community activists and district officials that have been involved in this mess since you received your approval will not sit and wait.  
They will demand transparency of you and the NJDOE.  

Thursday, July 5, 2012

Facing Eviction, Regis Finds New Facility While Districts Are Kept In The Dark.

My friend Jersey Jazzman mapped out the districts the Regis Academy says their students will come from and posited that Regis doesn't really seem to be offering much to warrant schlepping kids from a 50 mile radius.  


I hate to be the one to tell him, but he needs to redraw his map.


Seems that Regis, facing eviction from their current facility where Amir Khan also houses his church, Solid Rock Worchip Center, as well as many other ventures, has found themselves a new facility!  


How did the districts find out about the change of facility?  


It must have been at a Regis Board of Trustees Meeting, right?  Concerned citizens have attended EVERY meeting, to stay abreast of any big happenings.  After all, public dollars will be spent to educate Regis students, so the public has a right to have a say in how that money is spent.  


WRONG!  


There has been no mention of the change of facility at ANY Regis Meeting.  In fact, their website still uses the original address for the facility the Camden Diocese is evicting them from!

Well, then Amir Khan must have broke the news in the press!  He seems to LOVE talking to the press, even when the chips are down!


WRONG!


Just recently, perhaps even in the last few days, Amir Khan told WHYY reporter Jen Howard that he had struck a deal with the Diocese! 



Well, then the NJDOE must have let the districts know before they conducted that preparedness visit last week, which included a tour of the facility!  

WRONG!



In fact, unbeknownst to the districts, the preparedness visit was conducted at the NEW facility!



The districts found out when the address on the transportation requests they received from Regis did not match the address of the facility.  


Classic.


Here are the new supposed digs:



The biggest problem with this is simple.  If Regis can't afford the property they currently occupy, and Amir Khan was very clear that he needed the income from the charter to pay the bills, what makes the DOE think they can afford this property?  

Numerous concerned citizens have been emailing the Office of Charter Schools and Acting Commissioner Cerf trying to tell them that there are MASSIVE problems with this charter, but their cries are falling on deaf ears.  Jeanine Martin, interviewed in the WHYY piece, hand delivered her concerns, and those of almost 2,500 petition signers, to the NJDOE last week.  
Jeanine attempted to set up a meeting with Amy Ruck, Director of the Charter School Office, to deliver the materials in person, but of course, she was not granted a meeting and had to deliver her materials to the mailroom.

The NJDOE is totally out of control.  They are allowing unproven charter operators to run rampant, taking tax dollars from districts with little but empty promises of innovation in return.  

If Regis Academy is granted a final charter on July 15th, ostensibly allowing them to use taxpayer dollars to keep themselves afloat, EVERY New Jersey taxpayer should be OUTRAGED.

Newark Charter School Fund: What Role Do They Play In The Newark Charter School Takeover?

NJ Spotlight, the Star Ledger and Jersey Jazzman have all covered the "news" that Newark Superintendent Cami Anderson overruled the vote of the ELECTED Advisory Board to reject Anderson's plan to lease district school buildings to charters.  


Chairperson of the Advisory Board, Antoinette Baskerville-Richardson, spoke with NJ Spotlight. 


The chairman of the local board last night was very critical of the decision.
“The board members took this issue of leasing very, very seriously,” said Antoinette Baskerville-Richardson, recently elected as the board’s chairman. “At this point, what has happened is that the democratic rights of the voters we represent have been totally disrespected.”  (Emphasis mine)
Jersey Jazzman has already done a great job showing how outrageous it is that the Newark public schools are caught in a Chinese finger trap where no matter how hard they may struggle to get free of the state, the state's hold on the district only gets tighter.  
Jersey Jazzman also pointed out how unsurprising it is that Newark Mayor Corey Booker jumped behind Anderson's decision, using the same tired lines as Cerf, Anderson, and every other reformer in the state about "creating high-quality school options."  
I guess it doesn't sound as good to come right out and say they are privatizing public education.
But wait!  There is another voice in the choir singing the praises of "high-quality school options!"  
Let's take a look at the quotes from Newark Charter School Fund CEO Mashea Ashton in both the NJ Spotlight and Star Ledger pieces.   
(For the record, John Mooney and Jessica Calefati didn't reach out to her to get quotes, she put out a press release.  Here it is in it's entirety.)
Mashea Ashton, the CEO of the Newark Charter School Fund, issued the following statement regarding Newark School's Superintendent Cami Anderson's decision to veto the Newark Public Schools Advisory Board's vote on charter school leases. 
"Superintendent Cami Anderson should be applauded for making the tough decision to veto the school advisory board. Her decision to approve charter leases will expand the number of high quality public school options for all Newark students.
"Although the superintendent in Newark has the power to veto the advisory board, we believe this power should be exercised judiciously. In this case, it was without a doubt the right decision. It does not make sense for the district to maintain half-empty buildings while high-performing charters as well as new charters poised for breakthrough results cannot find space in the city to educate Newark children.
"What has become lost in this debate is that charter schools are public schools, funded with public dollars, educating the same Newark children as traditional district schools. It's time to put politics aside and move forward with this plan that will benefit all students in Newark."
Time to put politics aside!?!  More like time to put local control aside and force districts under state control to step aside while charters take over.  
Mashea Ashton is the CEO of the Newark Charter School Fund, having joined the organization as a partner in February 2009. Before joining NCSF, Mashea served as the Executive Director for the New York Program and Senior Advisor for Charter School Policy for New Leaders for New Schools. Mashea has also served as the Executive Director for Charter Schools for the New York City Department of Education, the National Director of Recruitment and Selection for the Knowledge is Power Program (KIPP), and as a special education teacher in Williamsburg, VA and Washington, DC.  (Emphasis mine)
That puts Ms. Ashton at the NYC DOE at the same time as Acting Commissioner Cerf for at least a year, if not more.  No big surprise that they are both advocates of charters taking over public schools since this practice is rampant in NYC.  
And what is the Newark Charter School Fund?  John Mooney describes it as "an advocacy and funding group for the city’s burgeoning charter school network," but let's take a peek at their website and see where their funding comes from.
NCSF was started with $18 million from national education foundations. NCSF’s founding sponsors — Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, The Doris and Donald Fisher Fund, The Robertson Foundation, and the Walton Family Foundation — each contributed $4 million in the spring of 2008 to establish NCSF. NCSF expects to raise an additional $2 million in national funding and to close out its initial funding base at $20 million. NCSF’s initial funding base will probably be dispersed over the next three to four years in support of Newark’s charter school sector.  (Emphasis mine)
Yeah, but Senator Ron Rice is a conspiracy theorist when he says that Newark's schools are being privatized.  They are pretty clear here that the money from the Billionaire Boys Club is to benefit the "charter school sector," not ALL of Newarks students.  But above Ms. Ashton claims that Anderson's plan will "benefit ALL students in Newark."  I think the folks in Chester Upland would beg to differ that the unchecked spread of charters is good for ALL students.

The district’s fiscal woes are the product of a toxic brew of budget cuts, mismanagement and the area’s poverty. Its problems are compounded by the Chester Community Charter School, a nonprofit institution that is managed by a for-profit company and that now educates nearly half of the district’s students.
The district sees the charter as a vampire, sucking up more than its fair share of scarce resources. The state, it says, is giving the charter priority over the district. 
“It’s not competition, it’s just draining resources from the district,” said Catherine Smith, a principal at Columbus Elementary, a district school. “It’s a charter school on steroids.” (Emphasis mine)
And I would contend that, with the convergence of the reform money pouring into the Newark Charter School Fund, the political clout of Mayor Booker, and the audacity and unaccountability of Acting Commissioner Cerf and his protege Cami Anderson, Newark's charters are poised to take over Newark in very short order.  
We all need to get behind the people of Newark to help get their voices heard. 
And fast.


The Final (Charter) Countdown

And the saga continues...

Let's break this one down a little:

Jeanine Martin of Voorhees isn't wild about public education dollars going to a church-run charter school. 

"We live in Voorhees because of the school system," said Martin. 

The mother of three has collected almost 2,500 signatures urging the Education Department to block Regis from opening.  Martin says she doesn't want her school to cut corners just so a new charter can open. 

"When Regis was approved, Voorhees was told to set aside $2 million of its budget for kids that may want to go to this Charter school. So, we knew that that was going to cut teachers and services," said Martin. "There's no way they could cover their costs and educate our kids to the way that they have."


Voorhees was asked to set aside 2M.  So how many kids from Voorhees have actually enrolled?  

TWELVE.

Does anyone else see how messed up this is?  Why are charters not forced to do surveys BEFORE they even submit their application?  If the parents in Voorhees had been asked if they were interested in this charter they could have said, "Yeah, no thanks, we're good."  They could have saved the district, and Voorhees parents like Jeanine Martin a lot of time and aggravation and the Department of Education a LOT of embarrassment.  


But Amir Khan can spin just about any situation. 


Solid Rock Pastor Amir Khan says his kids and grand kids attend Voorhees schools, too. But just because schools are high-performing doesn't mean they're for everyone.  

"We believe that one size doesn't fit. We believe that every parent should be able to have school choice," said Khan. "There is room for growth, there is room for innovation. We don't believe that public schools should be a monopoly." 


Well, clearly Pastor Khan has his reformy talking points down, but how exactly is Regis Academy going to provide "room for growth" and "room for innovation?"

Rev. Amir Khan, the controversial head of the Solid Rock Worship Center, says students at Regis Academy will receive their own Sprint tablet. Every classroom will be equipped with Blackboard, a multi-media learning platform more prevalent in colleges than elementary schools.
"We believe we can bring innovation and technology to children starting in kindergarten,” says Khan, who ran a telecommunications company, among other entrepreneurial ventures, before becoming a pastor. "There are ways advanced technology can be taught in basic formats to make it very interesting, such as opening up devices to see how they communicate from one phone to another or opening up computers to see how they establish a network.”  (emphasis mine)  

Seriously?  This is the best example he can come up with to explain how Regis will "bring innovation and technology to children?"

Clearly Regis wasn't able to sell this to the families of Voorhees, so where are the kids coming from?  According to the chart above, it is taking 33 districts to fill the seats at Regis Academy (up from 25 at last count).  And currently the most kids are coming from Lindenwold, where Geraldine Carroll is the Superintendent.  

Lindenwold was not a part of the Regis application, so Ms. Carroll had no way to know her students would even attend this charter.  But if Regis' enrollment numbers are correct, and Regis is awarded their final charter, her district could be out almost 500K.  

Check out this video about Ms. Carroll, who was recently named South Jersey Superintendent of the year.

Ms. Carroll has worked to get grants so that Lindenwold students can have access to a Smart Board in every classroom, document cameras, laptops, iPads, iPods, digital cameras, digital video cameras, and instant responders, and technology has been integrated cohesively into the curriculum. 

And Regis will take tax dollars from Lindenwold public schools so that students at Regis can... take apart their Sprint tablets to "see how they communicate?"

And don't miss this...

Solid Rock is also involved in a dispute that could lead to it being evicted from the building it rents from the Catholic Diocese of Camden. But Khan says a deal with the Diocese has been struck, and will settle in the next few weeks.   
A decision from the Department of Education is due by July 15th.



I will hopefully have more on this soon, but not for nothing, the NJDOE did their walkthrough of Regis' facility last week, and all documentation was due to the Office of Charter Schools by June 30.  If eviction proceedings were underway when the NJDOE did their walkthrough and may not be resolved before decisions are made on final charters on July 15th, how can the DOE even consider giving Regis their final charter, even if a "deal with the Diocese has been struck?"


Regis was one of only four charters approved in September of 2011, and this application round was hailed by the NJDOE as a "rigorous review process" and was held up as an example of the best practices in the nation!

This year, the Charter Schools Office continued to improve the application evaluation to align with national best practices identified by the National Association of Charter School Authorizers (NACSA). This included setting clear benchmarks around predictors of school success including a research-based academic program with a proven history, experienced school operators, high expectations for all students, a well-rounded board of trustees, and a strong capacity to implement program elements. These components, along with a number of others, were reviewed through a several stage process including an intensive interview with the evaluation committee.  NACSA also provided the Department with national charter experts to serve on the review committees in line with NACSA best practices.

Well guys, you all did a bang up job on this one...